1 - em.. - gee idk what I could say for constructive crits..well done sir- very classy count, the slight caricatural look works really well..he seems almost normal, until you see those eyes
2 - Disco Matt - your coloured uplit piece was nice, but the desaturated one is good too, with those omnipresent greys with dabs of red; really brings attention to the count with those glows
3 - Sonofwolfhound3 - I would agree with you and your girlfriend, what a creepy man - liking the sketchy-textured look of your piece
and for the rest:
Gunsing - like disco Matt, the sepia with speckles of red looks good - your moon blends in with the textured background you have, kinda makes it look like one giant moon, maybe it'd pop out more if it had a brighter rim? nice touch to have his cloak turn into a flock(?) of bats
Zinc - freaky old man, he almost looks normal; his pale skin contrasts really well with the purply background
Kodabble - props for going ahead with such a pose
mrFogg - liking that graphical style, makes your piece stand out, and there's no mistaking the count from what he really is
Sinstral - indeed, he might look normal at first glance, just gotta look for those lips - nice that they're the only really saturated part of the painting; his nose does seem a tad flat though
sugar - not much of his true nature showing, but that makes your count so much more dangerous - those are some beautiful hands you've painted
carnal- you certainly brought it all in, good job doing that - would've been nice if you brought in some more textures in, seing as the castlehas those crisp brick details and all; the hand holding the sword kinda looks like his left hand was pasted on top of his right hand the way those fingers are posed
gabriella - aww too bad you didn't enter your onyx-eyed count painting, definitely was my fav this week