Upload your portfolio today. Register here
 

Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

Last post 11-27-2007, 10:59 PM by banjaxedmdt. 18 replies.
Page 1 of 2 (19 items)   1 2 Next >
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  11-21-2007, 12:56 PM 63641

    Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    As the title says, please.




    http://sauronthedark.evony.com follow this url and register even if you don't wanna play..just for me!
  •  11-21-2007, 5:42 PM 63685 in reply to 63641

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    The Sword and sword effect look better, but i am curious as to why you dulled the background out so much?
    Art is where the Heart is.
    Stroke Attack Survivor (and that the way I talk the way I do.)
  •  11-22-2007, 12:07 AM 63758 in reply to 63685

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    Desaturated the background as I was thinking the character merged with it too much.



    http://sauronthedark.evony.com follow this url and register even if you don't wanna play..just for me!
  •  11-22-2007, 1:31 AM 63773 in reply to 63758

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    ok, just my thought - with all that fog/mist/dust around he should merge - maybe to pull him out wrap an aura of magic around him as he is holding a sword with lighting coming out of it.  like i said just my thought. all in all it is a very nice piece, but i have always been fond of swords and scorcery.(i think i spelled that right?)
    Art is where the Heart is.
    Stroke Attack Survivor (and that the way I talk the way I do.)
  •  11-22-2007, 1:10 PM 63834 in reply to 63773

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    dragon6261:
    ok, just my thought - with all that fog/mist/dust around he should merge - maybe to pull him out wrap an aura of magic around him as he is holding a sword with lighting coming out of it.  like i said just my thought. all in all it is a very nice piece, but i have always been fond of swords and scorcery.(i think i spelled that right?)

    Sorcery? 




    http://sauronthedark.evony.com follow this url and register even if you don't wanna play..just for me!
  •  11-22-2007, 1:16 PM 63835 in reply to 63834

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    yep that's the word, for some reason i always put a C in the begining of it
    Art is where the Heart is.
    Stroke Attack Survivor (and that the way I talk the way I do.)
  •  11-23-2007, 1:57 AM 63909 in reply to 63641

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    To say thanks to you commenting on my work, I had to repay the time, effort, and favor! :)

     

    First of all I have to say your hands are great - I am really jealous. I'm too scared to go that far. The positioning of the fingers seem just a tad off - he seems to be gripping a very narrow part of the sword - and it seems like it could be round. Try spreading the fingertips out a bit to give more of the effect of grasping something flatter and wider.

    The left arm looks wonderful - the positioning and everything, so perhaps on the right arm, change the angle a little to grasp the effect of the elbow being further away. Bring it in to the body just a bit.

    It also seems as if the hips are a bit narrow to the shoulders - it could just be the armor.

    Next just as a helpful suggestion, take a look at this ever expanding website: http://itchstudios.com/psg/art_tut.htm he has GREAT advice on speculars and lighting - especially for metal - it's amazing.

    My next advice would be to get Loomis' books - http://placidchaos.com/AM/index.php/2006/02/21/andrew_loomis the best one to start off with to at least read through would be Figure Drawing for all it's Worth.

     

    Otherwise it's a spectacular piece, there's many amazing points about it, just keep on truckin!

     

     

  •  11-23-2007, 3:22 PM 63967 in reply to 63909

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    Thanks both of you, there's been something about the anatomy which has been putting me off and haven't been able to put my finger on it. Gonna give your suggestions a go and see if they help. Yes



    http://sauronthedark.evony.com follow this url and register even if you don't wanna play..just for me!
  •  11-23-2007, 3:49 PM 63972 in reply to 63967

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    Here's a quick alteration using the liquify tool. Is is heading in the right direction?




    http://sauronthedark.evony.com follow this url and register even if you don't wanna play..just for me!
  •  11-23-2007, 4:21 PM 63979 in reply to 63972

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    The background is better, and since he metioned it, somethimg seems slighty out of adjustment with the left hand, but can't quite place it, or it could be me.  I like the piece though
    Art is where the Heart is.
    Stroke Attack Survivor (and that the way I talk the way I do.)
  •  11-23-2007, 4:49 PM 63983 in reply to 63979

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    Have adjusted the left hand slightly but maybe not enuff



    http://sauronthedark.evony.com follow this url and register even if you don't wanna play..just for me!
  •  11-23-2007, 5:39 PM 63994 in reply to 63983

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    Better, now it doesn't look like your holding something round, also i like the design on the armor, is that an original design
    Art is where the Heart is.
    Stroke Attack Survivor (and that the way I talk the way I do.)
  •  11-24-2007, 5:23 PM 64166 in reply to 63972

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    Very nice image ! You have done really well with his face...It reminds me a bit of the image on the Turin shroud, I like the peacefullness. I would perhaps give him a bit more contrast and shine on that armour - but that´s only my personal opinion.

    Very good ! Yes


    raimo
  •  11-24-2007, 5:35 PM 64170 in reply to 64166

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    Thanks Raimo, will try and update this soon.



    http://sauronthedark.evony.com follow this url and register even if you don't wanna play..just for me!
  •  11-25-2007, 5:14 PM 64319 in reply to 64170

    • em... is not online. Last active: 23-11-2009, 1:25 PM em...
    • Top 25 Contributor
    • Joined on 04-10-2007
    • SGC, Cheyenne Mountain Air Force Station
    • Posts 2,546

    Re: Crit please- Has this improved and what else does it need?

    Hi Martin,

    You asked me for my thoughts, so here are a couple of things that spring to mind - I did a quick scribble and a paintover to illustrate.

    I think that what's looking odd about his raised leg is twofold - firstly, raising a leg would raise the hips slightly on that side, and lead to an opposing action of the left shoulder for balance, creating a curve to the spine rather than the straight up and down that you have currently (red lines); secondly, the leg is sticking out sideways and side on when it should be more forwards, more of a three quarter view. This then leads to having to adjust the leg armour to looking like it's wrapping around a three dimensional object (green lines).

    An easier alternative might be re-doing his right leg so that it isn't bent.

    There is also an issue with the lighting, in that you have a very high contrast to the shadows on his face, but not on the body.

    I'm assuming that you are wanting a semi-religious type of feel, and so I would suggest emphasising the light from the window - cooling and darkening the midtones, lightening and warming the shaft and adding a rim light, so that he is "touched" by the light and warmth of God or whatever.

    I hope this is of some use to you.


Page 1 of 2 (19 items)   1 2 Next >
View as RSS news feed in XML